Friday, November 16, 2007
Students Suspended for Peaceful Protest (2:31 pm)
Students who participated in a November 1st rally for peace at Morton West High School in Berwyn, IL were suspended and may even face expulsion.
The students began their protest in the school’s cafeteria, and eventually moved it to the area designated by Superintendent Ben Nowakowski specifically for the protest. According to a statement released by Nowakowski, “[The protesters} were afforded the opportunity to take their protest outside where they would not be impeding the educational process and, if they did so, the would face no disciplinary action. Several members of the group elected to return to their classes.”
Though some students locked arms, fearing police action, they all eventually moved on. However, the punishments being dolled out are extreme and unfair. Reports say, “some students with lower grades were given 10-day suspensions and face expulsion, while students favored by officials were given only five-day suspensions and do not face expulsion.”
Here’s the kicker: These students weren’t just protesting the War. According to a CLTV/Tribune report “students say recruiters come to that school several times each week, hold competitions, tell them they should join the army—That’s what they were protesting.”
These students were not just protesting the Iraq war, they were protesting the recruiters that impede their educational process—the same thing these students are being punished for. Let me quote Superintendent Ben Nowakowski again, “The incident that led to the suspensions had everything to do with disruption of the school day. While we respect the rights of students to express their views, that must be done in such a way as to respect the rights of the other 3,400 students at Morton West who are entitled to a peaceful, disruption-free school day.”
There is a double standard here. The army can come to the schools each week and disrupt student flow and education, not to mention, target “psychologically immature kids” And yet students are punished for protesting recruitment. Hmm.
None of these children, regardless of their academic records, deserve to be expelled for acting upon the first amendment. If these children are to be punished for “disruption of the school day,” then it seems that army recruiters should be expelled as well.
posted by Intern
Reader Comments
really not surprising. Our rights and liberties have been eroding for the past seven years. the most unsettling aspect? most citizens don’t seem to care.
posted by Franklin M. Mock on 11-19-07 at 12:19 PM
Hmmm..... I wonder how long the staff of ITT would put up with a group showing up in the center of their offices staging a pro-troop/pro-Iraq victory rally. I’m thinking the police would be called immediately, and rightfully so.
I don’t think it makes much sense to compare the protest with a recruitment booth. Obviously, the recruiters are complying with school rules. The protesters are not. That’s really the point. It’s a school, not a town square.
posted by Natalie on 11-22-07 at 5:24 PM
This is an example of more of the zero tolerance nonsense that has pervaded schools as policy since 1993. Since when could students not protest a war that is robbing America of its promise. The very children that are supposed to be quiet while adults continue to go about robbing this country blind. Even the children know that one plus one equals two. So how is it that these adults in charge continue with not balancing the checkbook of America.
posted by Sharon Howard on 11-23-07 at 9:53 PM
No, I’m pretty sure this type of thing wouldn’t have been tolerated back in the days of Richie and Fonzie, either. Perhaps even less so.
They were free to take it off school grounds. Might have at least gotten some public attention that way.
You’re free to start your own super-tolerant school, and allow anything that feels good. Good luck getting any students. I know I wouldn’t send my kid there.
posted by Natalie on 11-24-07 at 11:53 AM
qnwpjmgh vdixijkk http://csoulnxz.com mlmoctou qezxtazn asqbvron
posted by mkrqvnow on 12-29-07 at 7:08 AM
lyutfbhe osrusyxy bqrdnwup http://wvppfkbe.com iwkpokig vcnqvulm
posted by ezocazdy on 12-29-07 at 7:09 AM
zrujrodb yhpjygbe http://uxdnecxx.com xmaruhkt lghcfyup dhebdejl
posted by yitxspwx on 12-29-07 at 7:09 AM
uiggpxer xufkkeah http://kfphfoyu.com rbxfwike mehdaixt kunfnbur
posted by bclxfgaw on 12-29-07 at 7:10 AM
lanwrqdf gvrkalft skpmffth http://oejzjluc.com ivgrwwsd slzdqhgz
posted by twqqpgoc on 12-29-07 at 7:10 AM
Discussion Closed
Commenting is closed on articles six months or older. This helps us prevent spam and maintain continuous discussions. We also close discussions from time to time that we are unable to moderate. Thanks for your understanding.
bastards also allow teachers to drone on for almost an hour at a time. Poor oppressed students!
posted by don on 11-19-07 at 10:25 AM